Friday, November 18, 2005

even MI5 against ID cards

BBC News: Ex-MI5 chief sparks ID card row

Even Stella Rimington (ex-head of MI5) thinks ID cards are a waste of time.

The argument put forward by the former government crime advisor Lord Mackenzie, that an ID card would have prevented the Soham murders (by preventing Huntley from getting the job in the first place), may well be true - but the existing system of safeguards should also have prevented him from getting the job in the first place, if Humberside police had been using it correctly. It is also cynical in the extreme to use this kind of emotive argument to try to whip up support for the flagging ID cards scheme.

Related articles: Ex-MI5 chief lukewarm on ID cards (16-11-05)
Minister rejects ID card fears (17-11-05)

No comments: